I'm standing in the fading light of a Bolivian fall
day, watching—along with much of the village of
Tahana—as Anthony Harckham, with tools and wires in
hand, heaves his 6-foot-plus Canadian frame onto the
corrugated steel roof of a small, mud-walled home. With
the glacial peaks of Mount Illampu, the northern bookend
to Bolivia's Cordillera Real, as a backdrop, Anthony
improvises a way to tack up a 15-by-20-centimeter solar
panel with wood screws, and then he feeds wires from the
panel under the eaves and into the home. I squeeze into
the home's small living space to watch Anthony and his
wife, Faith, connect the wires to a 12-volt lead-acid
battery pack, which is wired through a switch box to a
pair of lamps—transparent plastic boxes each jammed
with a dozen white light-emitting diodes, or LEDs. One
lamp hangs from a narrow ceiling beam, while a second is
located in an adjoining lean-to that serves as a
kitchen. The sun is all but gone when the Harckhams
finally flip a toggle switch and the LEDs jump to life
to cast a bluish beam of light, eliciting smiles from
the homeowners and their excited, chattering neighbors.
|
Bolivian Beat: The village of Tahana fetes its visitors with
a communal meal, including traditional drum and
panpipe music.
|
The Harckhams, a pair of 62-year-olds from Canmore,
Alta., Canada, have made it their mission to free remote
communities from reliance on costly kerosene lighting.
Their solution: LEDs, which convert electricity into
light relatively efficiently, powered by photovoltaic
cells, which can reliably generate the necessary
electricity from abundant sunlight. More than 1 billion
people globally lack electricity at home, but the
situation is particularly acute in Bolivia, one of South
America's poorest nations and its least electrified.
Just one out of every four rural communities in this
Andean nation enjoys consistent access to electric
power. Most of Bolivia's rural workers rely on sooty
kerosene lamps that fill their homes with thick, acrid
smoke. The Harckhams are offering these campesinos an
alternative. The simple LED lamp they developed—12
white LEDs mounted on a hand-soldered circuit
board—consumes only 1 watt and produces 30 lumens in a
focused beam about as bright as the light of a 20-W
incandescent bulb. It's not the profuse light we're
accustomed to, but it is enough to read, cook, or work by.
Yet the Harckhams' greatest insight is more about
people than technology. They devised a small volunteer
operation that blends tourism and charity: individuals
of means in developed countries help finance lighting
installations in the developing world. The operation,
called Luxtreks, has installed lighting systems in more
than 700 rural homes in Bolivia, Guatemala, Peru, and
Pakistan without taking a dime of government money.
Instead, Luxtreks trekkers pay the equivalent of about
US $750 apiece over and above the expense of their own
trips to cover the cost of lighting 20 homes. None of
the money is for profit, and the Harckhams pay their own
way. The trekkers travel with the couple and personally
deliver the gift by installing the LED lamps themselves.
At the same time, the trip provides trekkers a unique,
in situ experience about as culturally distant from
their daily lives as they could have imagined. "When you
step into one of those houses it's a pretty eye-opening
experience," says Anthony. "But it's not only being in
the homes. It's engagement. You're intimately involved
in the community."
I traveled to bolivia in
may to meet the Harckhams and to see
whether and how Luxtreks' trekkers and technology were
making a difference in the lives of rural villagers. Our
seven-person team would deviate from the Luxtreks norm:
my wife, Sara Beam, a historian, and I would be the
closest thing to trekkers, working like trekkers but not
contributing the financial premium. For this mission,
funding from a British charity, the Juniper Trust,
helped the Harckhams to cover the equipment costs. Also,
the mission would count on help from two agronomists and
a French student, all affiliates of Cecasem, a
nongovernmental organization based in Bolivia's
administrative capital, La Paz, that promotes rural
development. We would not only install Luxtreks lighting
systems in Tahana but would also visit two neighboring
villages to do something the Harckhams had never done
before: inspect lighting systems installed by Luxtreks
in years past.
|
The hillsides of the Bolivian Andes are home
to many villages like Tahana, where power lines
don't go and families rely instead on sooty
kerosene lamps that fill their homes with a
thick, acrid smoke.
|
In the weeks prior to the trip, the country seemed
poised to descend into political chaos over government
policies favoring export of the country's natural gas,
an initiative opposed by many working Bolivians who feel
that foreign energy firms are pumping away the country's
natural wealth. As we prepared to depart for Bolivia,
campesinos were threatening to block the roads,
prompting an acquaintance of the Harckhams in Bolivia to
warn against making the trip. But the Harckhams were
unfazed. They have come to expect roadblocks in their
journey—though usually not such literal ones—and they
took Bolivia's political strife in stride. We would go
to Bolivia and we would reach our destination in the
Andes. As it turned out, fortunately, we faced no
roadblocks.
What we found in the villages would show both the
daring and the shortcomings of the Luxtreks formula. I
would discover that the operation is still a work in
progress. Bolivia would force the Harckhams to
reevaluate their commitment to Luxtreks and, ultimately,
to reinvent both their technology and their working
relationship with the rural peoples they serve.
Tahana is a village of
44 families eking out a living growing
potatoes, corn, tea, and other foodstuffs on fertile but
steep and rapidly eroding slopes. To reach Tahana our
group travels by truck for four hours on unevenly paved
highways, going from La Paz to the market and trekking
town of Sorata. From there we hire an open-bed Toyota
Land Cruiser and travel another two hours, now braced in
the back amidst 3000 meters of wire, 90 kilograms of
batteries, and hundreds of LED lamps, switch boxes, and
solar panels. At the end of the road, where the power
lines stop, we are met by a dozen men from Tahana and
several donkeys. The plan is to take the gear down to a
gully and then back up a kilometer-long trail to the
village. It is the villagers' second encounter with
Luxtreks. Two years earlier, a Luxtreks team hiked
through Tahana, en route to light up a neighboring
village a few hundred meters upslope, prompting a
petition from Tahana residents for systems of their own.
Now the Canadians are back.
|
Handy Light: Residents of Tahana received LED lamps for
their homes, churches, and school. Each lamp has
a dozen white LEDs that fit into a transparent
plastic case.
|
We arrive late in the afternoon and, after a formal
welcome from the secretarios—a rotating council of
landholding men—we set up shop in the school, which has
been idled by a nationwide teachers' strike; we'll use
it as a base where we'll assemble components, take our
meals, and strategize. As night falls, we eat and then
head to our tents for sleep. We are excited and at the
same time apprehensive, knowing that some hard work lies ahead.
In the morning, the two agronomists in our
party—Cecilio Quispe and Estanislao Poma—take the lead
and craft an installation plan. They are fluent in
Aymará, an indigenous language common in the Bolivian
Andes, and they know the villagers, having worked with
them through Cecasem to build irrigation systems,
upgrade ovens, and organize agricultural cooperatives.
As the intense high-altitude sunlight boils away the
chill of the morning, we set off with lighting kits in
hand. Anthony and Poma will work the rooftops,
installing the 2-W solar panels, which the Harckhams had
custom built by a manufacturer in China. The rest of us
split into teams to wire up the lamps containing the
LEDs, these bought from a distributor in Hong Kong.
That morning I work alongside Morgane Richomme, the
French development student, who was then just a few
weeks into a two-month stint with Cecasem. Our team also
includes three villagers: Roberto Mamani, Mario Condori
(one of the secretarios), and his son Vitaliano. The
three Bolivians watch as we connect all the pieces of
the circuit: solar panel to battery, battery to switch,
switch to lights. Soon they are pitching in, and by
early afternoon they have seized the initiative and our
tools. As they work feverishly by themselves, I reflect
on how Richomme and I went, in a matter of hours, from
installers to instructors and have now been relegated to
quality control.
Freed from active
duty, I go back to being a journalist. I see
the humility and hospitality of the villagers whose
homes we invade for half an hour or more with crimpers,
cables, and semiconductors. I play with the kids, racing
them on supply runs along twisting paths. I marvel at
the villagers' intimate cohabitation with animals: in
tightly walled yards shaded by trees filled with ripe
passion fruit, women grind meal among ducks, pigs,
goats, and other creatures. Guinea pigs scurry at my
feet like a moving carpet on the dirt and
eucalyptus-plank floors.
|
Turning it on: An LED lamp installed in the home of a family
in Tahana.
|
One man welcomes us to tour his orchard and garden,
his honey-producing hives, and his cactus-gorging herd
of cochineal insects, which produce the deep red dye
common in Andean textiles. I ask him how the villagers
can take so much time away from their regular duties to
work and talk with us. The man explains that they are
between harvests and also that it is a "special
opportunity" to have us there.
When dusk finally sets in, I experience the dark
side—literally—of the campesinos' standard lighting
source. As the villagers ignite kerosene lamps that are
little more than torches, smoke fills each small, nearly
windowless home. The kerosene fumes contain particulates
and carcinogenic gases that are a major cause of eye and
respiratory diseases in the developing world, especially
among women, who stay at home for much of the day. With
my own eyes burning, I think also of the fire hazard as
I watch a girl, perhaps three years old, plucking long
black hairs from her head and dangling them in a flame.
During those three exhausting days in Tahana, the
closest we come to taking a shower is dunking our heads
in a public sink, and we endure vicious attacks from las
pulgas—fleas that infest our tents and sleeping bags,
teaching us the hard way why roosters and dogs become
symphonic at 3 in the morning. But we also get a rare
and sublime sort of thrill bringing clean light to the
village, including every one of its homes, the school,
and two churches.
Luxtreks got to
Bolivia, interestingly, through the
Harckhams' evolving relationship with a place thousands
of miles away, in southern Asia. For many years, the
couple supported a schoolteacher in the remote village
of Norung in Nepal. In 1998, Faith, a retired
physiotherapist who now sells paintings to tourists
visiting the Canadian Rockies, and Anthony, once R and D
manager for the Alberta phone company and now a
technology management consultant, traveled to Norung to
visit the village and help build a new schoolhouse.
During that trip, when the Harckhams asked the villagers
what they needed most, their answer was light—electric
light—which would free them from costly and smoky
kerosene lamps.
The Harckhams found the technological solution an
hour's drive from home. David Irvine-Halliday, an
electrical engineering professor at the University of
Calgary, Alta., Canada, who had been in Nepal himself,
had been just as moved as the Harckhams were by the dark
homes and schools, and was working on a solution. In the
spring of 2000, Irvine-Halliday and his wife, Jenny,
returned to Nepal with LED lamps and lit up several
villages, an initiative that would evolve into the Light
Up the World Foundation. Irvine-Halliday's idea is to
create local manufacturers of LED lighting systems to
serve remote communities like the ones in Nepal. For the
Harckhams, his LED lamps provided a drop-in solution to
Norung's kerosene habit. Later that same year, the
Harckhams returned to Norung with $3000 worth of
photovoltaics, batteries, and white LED lights assembled
in Nepal's capital, Kathmandu, to Irvine-Halliday's
specs. Working with the villagers, the couple lit up
Norung in a matter of days. Luxtreks was conceived to
continue and expand that initiative, and by late 2002,
the Harckhams had scheduled Luxtreks' first trip.
Destination: Bolivia.
Eight trekkers signed up for that Bolivian mission.
The plan was to light up 120 homes in two villages:
Quirambaya, an hour's hike from Sorata, and Pocobaya,
just above Tahana. Pulling it off would test the
Harckhams. They were counting, again, on
Irvine-Halliday's help with the LED lamps, but this time
the Calgary professor couldn't deliver. Busy debugging
circuitry for a second generation of lamps, he didn't
have time to arrange the lamps for the Harckhams. So
they improvised. Through friends—and friends of
friends—Anthony found a local company willing to design
a similar circuit for free. He ordered the necessary
components, and he and Faith assembled their own lamps.
Their system at that time also consisted of two LED
lamps, plus one switch box with a current-limiting
circuit and a battery, to be charged once a week at a
central charging station powered by 75-W solar panels.
Once on the ground in Bolivia, the Harckhams faced
further logistical hurdles and plenty of anxiety. Would
the lights work as expected? Did they have enough wire
and tools? Could they manage the trekkers? On top of
that, their relationship with their initial local
contacts—a couple living in La Paz—fell apart during
the trip. The couple, whom the Harckhams had contacted
through Irvine-Halliday, had identified Pocobaya and
Quirambaya as candidates for LED lighting and had helped
the Harckhams with travel arrangements and local
logistics. But a series of misunderstandings and
disagreements over the project's specifics, beginning
with the Harckhams' decision to improvise their own
as-yet-untested lamps, soured relations between the two
couples, severing a key line of communication with the
villagers for the Harckhams, who spoke little Spanish,
let alone Aymará.
In the end, despite these and other difficulties, the
equipment arrived in time, the homes were lit, and the
trekkers were satisfied. Tom Malaher, one of several
people from Calgary on that mission, recalls the trip as
an eye-opening adventure. "It certainly made us aware of
the differences in economic and technological levels
that exist," he says. "You hear about this stuff on the
news, and you see really low-quality TV images, but you
don't really know what it means because the TV frame is
so narrow."
Still, one element was missing for Faith and Anthony:
the kind of connection with villagers that they had
experienced in Nepal. "We got some help from the
villages, but not as much as we'd anticipated," recalls
Anthony. "We didn't really sense that we'd touched the
community in quite the same way as we had in Nepal."
That disconnect would have profound consequences, as we
would discover during our return visit.
As soon as we
arrive in Pocobaya and Quirambaya, it is
clear things are not quite right two years after
installation. Only about half of the lighting systems in
both villages are working; the rest are in varying
states of disrepair. We find solar panels disconnected,
charging stations burned out, switch boxes that don't
switch, lamps whose glued-on glass faceplates have come
unglued, LED circuits impregnated with soot, and wires
patched, broken, or missing. It is a far cry from the
claim on the Luxtreks Web site that the villages "should
be assured of their lighting for years to come." At
Pocobaya's schoolhouse, LED lamps have been ripped out
and a photo of a deceased friend to whom the Harckhams
had dedicated the lights removed from the wall. Faith
says she feels betrayed. She is stunned that, in her
eyes, the villagers seem not to have taken care of the
systems. "Anthony, I think we need to rethink what we're
doing," she tells her partner.
My own impression is that the technology is
underengineered. The wires, for example, are thin and,
exposed to the elements both inside and outside the
campesinos' mud homes, seem prone to fail. The glue
fastening the lamps' faceplates looks inadequate,
especially given the need to clean them in the smoky
homes. And the idea of a central charging station for
the batteries doesn't seem to quite work—with no formal
caretaker, it fell into disrepair.
|
Each lamp is attached to the ceiling with
screws and wired to a battery, which is then
connected to a 2-watt solar panel.
|
We spend a full day in Quirambaya and half a day in
Pocobaya doing what we can to swap in new lamps, switch
boxes, and battery connectors. To encourage regular
maintenance, Faith agrees to pay one man in each village
the equivalent of $6 to $8 every month (a significant
sum in a region where many campesinos earn no more than
$400 a year) to check the village's systems regularly
and send reports to Luxtreks. As the Harckhams and the
villagers hammer out these maintenance contracts, the
tone of the negotiations disturbs me. With Poma as
translator, Anthony and Faith make it clear that, in
their minds, the villagers had not lived up to their end
of the bargain.
The day that we
depart the hillside villages around Sorata,
roadblocks were sporadically halting traffic to La Paz.
But during our drive, my mind remains in the Andean
villages. I am puzzled by how Luxtreks' projects could
yield such seemingly divergent results in the places we
visited. Was the exhilaration I experienced in Tahana
real? Or would their lamps develop problems, as many had
in Pocobaya and Quirambaya? And ultimately, can a couple
of Canadians really make a difference in rural Bolivia?
Looking back after several months, I think they can.
Though far from perfect, the technology transfer that
the Harckhams are trying to pull off is of great benefit
to most of the villagers. In Pocobaya and Quirambaya,
most of the owners of broken systems were eager to see
them fixed. Andrew Canessa, a sociologist and director
of the Centre for Latin American Studies at the
University of Essex, in Colchester, England, who has
worked in Pocobaya for 15 years, says the lamps were in
regular use when he last visited the village in 2003.
"In my opinion, this is a good example of how a little
help can go a long way," Canessa told me in an e-mail.
Canessa says the light seemed particularly valued by the
women, who spend much time indoors cooking in poorly lit
kitchens, and among students who desire to do homework.
Village women affirmed Canessa's impressions. Josefina,
a bright-eyed 65-year-old grandmother in Tahana, told me
that the LED's bluish beam is "not like
electricity"—meaning not equal to the bright warm glow
of the lights in nearby villages connected to the power
grid—but that the LED lamps are a big step up from the
kerosene lamps.
|
Anthony Harckham demonstrates how to install
the solar panels on a roof.
|
The intimate connection that Luxtreks experienced in
Tahana, and the villagers' intense engagement in the
installation process, suggests that the systems will be
even more valued there, where people have a greater
sense of "ownership" of their lamps. "Successful
projects must start from a perceived need by the
intended recipient, and that need should be perceived by
them as a priority, or they won't be willing to pay for
it with their money, voluntary work, or time," says
Francis Lethem, a development expert with the Duke
Center for International Development at Duke University,
in Durham, N.C.
Like most engineering
projects, the Luxtreks operation faces
problems and failures. With them, the Harckhams have
learned that they must constantly rethink their
initiative and, above all, that both human and technical
factors are important for its success. During our trip,
Faith came up with a better strategy with which to
approach villages: the initial contacts would happen
through preinstallation visits, in which they would hope
to gauge and confirm the villagers' commitment to the
project. Meanwhile, Anthony worked to develop a more
robust lighting system. The result is a radical
redesign: Anthony packaged the LEDs, battery, and
photovoltaics into one self-contained lantern. The
lantern could be placed in the sunlight to charge and
could then be hung inside at night.
Irvine-Halliday says he has "nothing but admiration"
for the Harckhams and for Luxtreks—an "affiliate" of
his Calgary-based Light Up the World Foundation—but he
continues to advocate a different strategy:
jump-starting production and distribution of lamps in
the developing world financed by the rural poor
themselves. He says that the cost of a locally
manufactured lighting system is nearly within reach for
the rural poor and that microcredit financing, proven in
places like Bangladesh and now spreading through the
developing world, could provide the required capital.
Until rural people around the world can walk into shops
and buy their own LED lamps, I hope that Luxtrekkers
keep on making the journey.
|
An LED lamp consuming only 1 watt can provide
enough light to read, cook, or work by.
|
Half a year
later, my thoughts still return to our final
afternoon on the hillsides below Mount Illampu. Our work
in the three villages finished, we gather with the
residents of Tahana on the soccer field, where they fete
us with a traditional communal meal. A dozen men,
dressed in their best suits and intricately woven
serapes, strike up a mesmerizing, seemingly endless
melody on drums and zampoñas, Andean panpipes. Before
long I'm trading my denim baseball cap for a black
fedora and bright serape from one of my new
acquaintances, 33-year-old Víctor Peralta. Meanwhile,
the women in our group are layered in traditional satin
and cotton dresses. Moments later, as we twist around
the field in a chain dance, accelerated to the point of
hilarity, I realize that the villagers have made a
difference in our lives as much as we have perhaps made
in theirs.